I know the story of Watchmen. I know it very well. The reputation the book had of being ‘unfilmable’ was well earned. I say ‘was’ because Snyder blew me away. The biggest take-away I had was that it was the first movie I saw that was paced like a comic book. Sure, Sin City was an amazingly recreation of the story (with all it’s strengths and weaknesses) but it was paced like a movie. It used all the shots from the book, but they would speed up or slow down. Watchmen took it’s time.
I get the concerns with the slow motion fighting, but for me, it worked, because in comics you might get three panels of a single fight move, how else can you tell that story, except to slow it down and let you catch every blow just as they would happen for an individual trained to the utmost in their fighting.
There was no squid. For me, the squid was a huge mind-fuck in the comic. It was out of nowhere. The new ending (not to ruin it) felt organic, and if you did not know, it felt like the original ending. It kept it more contained and removed the subplot of the writer of The Black Freighter, which I do look forward to seeing on dvd. Snyder busted his balls on this and it shows. Alan Moore might not care to ever watch it, but to Alan I say what I have had to say to many fanboys over the years. At the end of the day: “It’s just a comic book”. Just like I will also say “It’s just a movie”.
- Watching: Burn Notice
- Listening: Kidney Thieves
- Reading: Apathy and Other Small Victories
- Playing: Little Big Planet
- Creating: 1 Page Comic